Scientific Evidence Supports Customary and Backup (Conditional) Spanking by Parents: Update of Larzelere and Baumrind (2010) and Fuller (2009)

12 Pages Posted: 30 Dec 2019

See all articles by Robert Larzelere

Robert Larzelere

Oklahoma State University

Jason Fuller

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Date Written: October 25, 2019

Abstract

This outline provides pincite references to research that supports appropriate disciplinary spanking, in contrast to the predominantly correlational evidence that the APA and AAP use to oppose all spanking. It summarizes meta-analyses that are ignored in scientific summaries that oppose spanking. And it includes evidence that backup spanking and phased-out spanking result in better outcomes compared to never-spanked children.

Two major publications in the past year indicate two things: First, correlational evidence against spanking is trivial after adjusting for preexisting child differences. And that trivial evidence is either harmful or helpful on average, depending on the statistical method used to adjust for preexisting differences.

Second, allegedly adverse effects of spanking are identical to the apparent effects of most corrective actions, when analyzed in the same way (e.g., longitudinal analyses controlling statistically for initial differences in outcome). This is true whether the corrective actions are by parents (e.g., other disciplinary responses) or professionals (e.g., treatments for depression in women).

Keywords: corporal punishment, spanking, physical punishment, corporal discipline, physical discipline, smacking, ban, methodology

JEL Classification: K36, I3, I30, Z1, Z10, Z13, Z18, I18, I28, I12, I20, I38

Suggested Citation

Larzelere, Robert and Fuller, Jason, Scientific Evidence Supports Customary and Backup (Conditional) Spanking by Parents: Update of Larzelere and Baumrind (2010) and Fuller (2009) (October 25, 2019). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3500544 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3500544

Robert Larzelere (Contact Author)

Oklahoma State University ( email )

Dept. Of Human Devel. & Family Science
233 Human Sciences Bldg.
Stillwater, OK Oklahoma 74078-0001
United States
4057449938 (Phone)
74078-0001 (Fax)

Jason Fuller

affiliation not provided to SSRN ( email )

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
155
Abstract Views
644
rank
247,195
PlumX Metrics