Ethnic Cleansing and Genocidal Intent: Conceptualizing Destruction of Local Populations

46 Pages Posted: 16 Feb 2021

See all articles by Hannibal Travis

Hannibal Travis

Florida International University College of Law

Date Written: February 1, 2021

Abstract

Atrocities against an identifiable group may qualify as genocide even though most members of the group take flight and the group survives the campaign against it. This type of scenario, widely known as “ethnic cleansing,” may lead to an inference of genocidal intent because of the atrocities themselves, statements reflecting religious or ethnonational hatred, disruption of family and communal life, and other patterns involving targeting group members and discriminating against them. Drawing on political philosophy as well as 75 years of domestic and foreign jurisprudence, this article proposes a “lifeworld”-based approach to genocidal intent. This approach explains and justifies the outcome in several decisions over the past decade and a half in cases involving accusations of genocide in Darfur, Srebrenica, the municipalities of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Cambodia. A lifeworld-based approach inquires into whether an ethnic cleansing campaign was conducted in such a manner as to leave the targeted group without a viable homeland in which to exist and thrive. If the accused’s actions are consistent with depriving the group of the means to perpetuate itself in the relevant locality, courts infer genocidal intent even if the entire group was not killed as soon as practicable, and even if a major component of the group was not killed.

As the ad hoc tribunals in The Hague and the hybrid tribunal in Phnom Penh wrap up their cases charging genocide and other international crimes, it is an opportune time to revisit the social and legal concept of genocide. Contrasting several potential approaches to genocidal intent, the article illustrates why international criminal tribunals have gravitated over the past decade towards a broader view of an “intent to destroy” a group “in whole or in part.” Policies that persecute and discriminate against a group in a locality such as a city, region, or province may include one or more of the acts listed in Article II of the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide and in Article 6 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. The text and drafting history of Article II of the Genocide Convention--as well as state practice in enforcing and implementing it--lead judges to conclude that genocidal intent may be inferred from such policies. Mass killing, infliction of trauma and fear prompting widespread flight of displaced persons, deprivation of homes and livelihoods, separation of families, and interruption of both physical and cultural reproduction justify inferences of genocidal intent. These are also the patterns of atrocity that exemplify ethnic cleansing.

The diplomats and jurists who abstractly defined the crime of genocide, as well as the prosecutors and judges who applied it to concrete cases, have clarified that genocide’s “intent to destroy” does not require a total genocide or whole-group targeting. The article surveys the relevant jurisprudence of the International Criminal Court, the International Court of Justice, the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, the Extraordinary Chambers of the Courts of Cambodia, and the United States, German, Bosnian, and Iraqi courts.

Keywords: treaty interpretation, genocidal intent, intent to destroy, Genocide Convention, Rome Statute, United States Code, international criminal courts, ad hoc tribunals, hybrid tribunal

JEL Classification: K33, N44, N45, F51, F52, F53, F54, F55

Suggested Citation

Travis, Hannibal, Ethnic Cleansing and Genocidal Intent: Conceptualizing Destruction of Local Populations (February 1, 2021). Global Studies Law Review, Vol. 19, No. 4, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3780188

Hannibal Travis (Contact Author)

Florida International University College of Law ( email )

11200 SW 8th St.
RDB Hall 1097
Miami, FL 33199
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
66
Abstract Views
299
rank
431,700
PlumX Metrics