Liminal Labor Law

58 Pages Posted: 1 Jun 2021 Last revised: 8 Jul 2021

See all articles by Michael M Oswalt

Michael M Oswalt

Northern Illinois University College of Law

Date Written: May 30, 2021

Abstract

How do people, organizations, and even movements bounce back from losses and setbacks? For organized labor, the disappointments are routinely legal: an overturned precedent, a loss of coverage, or even the accelerated degradation of the National Labor Relations Act (Act) regime itself. In aggregate, these and other law-based defeats pose a serious, even existential, threat to unions. And yet, the labor movement does not just forge ahead, it renews, shape-shifts, and, in many circles, energizes. This article suggests that the legal setbacks, and the persistence, are sometimes connected. Put otherwise, the way labor law is bad is sometimes linked to the movement’s resiliency. In making this case, the article argues that the law’s deficiencies often force movement actors and institutions to operate within “in-between” spaces: precedential instability means rules often exist between what a current decision says it is and predictions about when a future decision will say it is not; organizing protections can hang in a balance between NLRB-created identity poles; and if labor law might range from no rights to great rights, current rights rest, and frequently backslide, between those two extremes. These and other legal in-betweens are ultimately corrosive to collective bargaining and must be fixed. But in the meantime, there is increasing academic, business, and even pop-empirical evidence that in-between or, as described in cultural anthropology, “liminal” states are ripe for creative thought, new relational commitments, and beneficial change. How these and other liminal effects might be located within the labor movement are explored through three very recent case studies involving reversed joint-employer precedent, graduate student misclassification, and the Trump NLRB’s aggressive attempts to further limit the role of collective bargaining in American life.

Keywords: Labor Law Reform, NLRA, Strikes, Victor Turner, Organizing, Graduate Students, Joint Employer, Clean Slate, Organizing

JEL Classification: J51, J52, J53, J81, J83

Suggested Citation

Oswalt, Michael M, Liminal Labor Law (May 30, 2021). California Law Review, Vol. 110, 2022, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3856671

Michael M Oswalt (Contact Author)

Northern Illinois University College of Law ( email )

Swen Parson Hall
DeKalb, IL 60115
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
74
Abstract Views
352
rank
424,545
PlumX Metrics