And then There Were Four: A Study of UK Audit Market Concentration - Causes, Consequences and the Scope for Market Adjustment

University of Stirling Discussion Paper No. 03/03

25 Pages Posted: 21 May 2003

See all articles by Vivien A. Beattie

Vivien A. Beattie

Lancaster University - Lancaster University Management School

Alan Goodacre

University of Stirling - Department of Accounting and Finance

Stella Fearnley

Portsmouth Business School

Abstract

While concentration measures are a good indicator of market structure, the link with competitiveness is more complex than often assumed. In particular, the modern theory of industrial organisation makes no clear statement regarding the impact of concentration on competition - the focus of this paper is concentration and no inferences are made about competitive aspects of the market. The extent and nature of concentration within the UK listed company audit market as at April 2002 and, pro forma, after the collapse of Andersens is documented and analysed in detail (by firm, market segment and industry sector). The largest four firms held 90% of the market (based on audit fees) in 2002, rising to 96% with the demise of Andersens. A single firm, PricewaterhouseCoopers, held 70% or more of the share of six out of 38 industry sectors, with a share of 50% up to 70% in a further seven sectors. The provision of non-audit services (NAS) by incumbent auditors is also considered. As at April 2002 the average ratio of non-audit fees (paid to auditor) to audit fees was 208%, and exceeded 300% in seven sectors. It is likely, however, that recent disposals by firms of their management consultancy and outsource firms, combined with the impact of the Smith Report on audit committees will serve to reduce these ratios. Another finding is that audit firms with expertise in a particular sector appeared to earn significantly higher non-audit fees from their audit clients in that sector. The paper thus provides a solid empirical basis for debate. The subsequent discussion considers the implications for companies and audit firms of the high level of concentration in the current regulatory climate, where no direct regulatory intervention is planned.

Keywords: auditor concentration, concentration ratios, audit firm mergers

JEL Classification: M49, L84

Suggested Citation

Beattie, Vivien and Goodacre, Alan and Fearnley, Stella, And then There Were Four: A Study of UK Audit Market Concentration - Causes, Consequences and the Scope for Market Adjustment. University of Stirling Discussion Paper No. 03/03, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=389544 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.389544

Vivien Beattie (Contact Author)

Lancaster University - Lancaster University Management School ( email )

Bailrigg
Lancaster, LA1 4YX
United Kingdom

Alan Goodacre

University of Stirling - Department of Accounting and Finance ( email )

Stirling, FK9 4LA
United Kingdom
+44 1786 467291 (Phone)
+44 1786 467308 (Fax)

Stella Fearnley

Portsmouth Business School ( email )

Accounting & Management Science
Locksway Road
Southsea, PO4 8JF
United Kingdom
00-44-1202-706895 (Phone)
00-44-1202-706895 (Fax)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
611
Abstract Views
3,486
rank
57,671
PlumX Metrics